Honest, independent reviews and stories from one drinker working through 100 drams — the affordable, the everyday, and the worth-knowing.
General • 14 November 2026
The how-to guides tell you to print tasting sheets, share the line-up and finish on the peat. The people who host whisky tastings for a living put their effort somewhere else. I spoke to hosts at distilleries, shops, festivals and hired rooms around the country about what really makes a tasting work, and almost none of it is in the glass.
Read more →
My two Mystery Drop 4.0 boxes have arrived, and after September's pair of identical Bunnahabhain 12s this round could hardly have been more different. A Macallan Rare Cask and a Highland Park 16 Year Old, both from the Heavy Hitters tier, and both bottles I'd never have bought at full price. Here's what they're worth and what I make of it.
Orkney's other distillery finally has a proper age-statement core range, and the 10 year old is a cracking start. Full ex-bourbon maturation brings pineapple, mango, vanilla custard and gentle spice, with a lovely creamy texture. Bottled at 48%, non-chill-filtered and, I believe, naturally coloured, it's a world away from the old NAS releases. Highland Park has some serious competition.
Master of Malt's Mystery Drop is back on 20 October, and this time it's Macallan, Highland Park and The Glenrothes, with a £37,000 Glenrothes 51 Year Old as the headline prize. I've worked through the odds, the value of the average box against its £80 price, and the duplicate risk of buying more than one, so you can decide whether it's worth your money.
Master of Malt has eighteen whisky advent calendars on sale for 2026, from a £99.95 entry box to an £8,499.95 cabinet. I've been through the range, worked out what each dram costs, and picked where I'd actually spend my money. The cheapest is still the best value, my own pick costs twice as much, and two Highland Park doors are worth nearly a fifth of the price.
Diageo's 2022 Special Release takes Talisker in an unexpected direction: lightly peated and surprisingly balanced. Citrus and stone fruit lead over restrained smoke, with genuine coastal character throughout. Naturally coloured, non-chill-filtered at 55.1% ABV, this shows real skill in cask selection. A departure from typical Talisker, but executed with genuine confidence.
I bought two boxes in Master of Malt's September Mystery Drop, the themed CVH round with the £13,000 Bunnahabhain 35 Year Old as the headline prize. Both boxes contained the exact same bottle: a Bunnahabhain 12. Here's the maths on how likely that actually was, what it means for the value case, and why it hasn't put me off the format one bit.
Master of Malt's Mystery Drop returns for a third time on 10 September, and this one's different: every bottle comes from Bunnahabhain, Tobermory, Ledaig or Deanston, with a £13,000 Bunnahabhain 35 Year Old as the headline prize. I bought into the last round, so here's what it actually feels like, whether it's worth your money, and why I think MoM keeps running it.
Glenglassaugh's coastal Highland distillery has truly found its voice with this triple-cask expression. Stone fruits, honey, and maritime character blend beautifully at 45% ABV with proper production ethics. After over two decades of silence, they've launched a flagship that shows real skill and ambition. Worth seeking out if you want something that stands apart.
GlenAllachie's peated Speyside is only five years old, but it doesn't taste it. The Sherry One brings dark chocolate, toffee, and peat smoke together with genuine complexity. Matured in bourbon then finished in PX and Oloroso, it's non-chill-filtered and naturally coloured at 48%. A proper whisky that punches above its age and price.
Ledaig is Tobermory's peated expression from the Isle of Mull, and this 10 year old has quietly built a cult following among those wanting proper island peat without eye-watering Islay prices. Non-chill-filtered, naturally coloured and bottled at 46.3%, it promises medicinal smoke, briny salt and bright citrus. Is the value-star reputation all hype, or does it actually deliver? Spoiler: it does…
Glenmorangie is a name even non-drinkers recognise, and the Quinta Ruban is their port-finished Highlander — now 14 years old after extending its time in ruby port pipes to four years. Port finishes can be hit or miss, so does this one earn its benchmark reputation? Expect dark fruits, chocolate-covered cherries and a silky, non-chill-filtered texture, with gentle spice keeping the sweetness honest.
Compass Box divides opinion — boundary-pushing innovators to some, fancy bottles and marketing to others. Orchard House is their fruit-forward blended malt, and it's exactly what it promises: bright apple, pear and pineapple over golden syrup and buttery pastry, finishing on fruit and vanilla buttercream. A genuinely easy-drinking showcase of Scotch's lighter side — but is bright and breezy enough to win me over?
Sign up to get occasional news and updates straight to your inbox. No spam — just the odd note when there’s something worth sharing.
We use Google Analytics to understand how the site is used. Analytics cookies are only set if you accept. See how we handle data in our privacy policy.